Science fiction vs. real science: the influence of the "CSI effect" on the prosecution of felony cases
Science fiction vs. real science: the influence of the "CSI effect" on the prosecution of felony cases
No Thumbnail Available
Issue Date
2010
Authors
Harrington, Rosalyn D.
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Abstract
Since its inception into our lives, television has become a staple in mainstream America. For some, situations are not true unless it is seen or talked about on television. Television is a reality in areas beyond one’s knowledge or experience. With the continuous advancement in science and its perception on our lives, forensic science has taken a leading role in what is portrayed as real life crime drama. Yet, reality in the spectrum of criminal trials is forensic evidence. There are numerous television shows that center around law enforcement and the solvability factors needed to close a case. There is great impact on America known as the “CSI Effect” and the stronghold on potential jurors and those that have the task of prosecuting cases across the country. This research explored the influence of the “CSI Effect” on the prosecution of felony cases in a large urban community. Using focus group interviews, this qualitative phenomenological study examined the perceptions of the impact that the “CSI Effect” has on their preparation and prosecution of felony homicide cases. Results found that potential jurors expect felony trial cases to have forensic evidence, to include, but not limited to, that which is seen on television as it pertains to crime drama shows. However, there is a small percentage of attorneys that feel more research needs to be obtained to gather results.
Description
Keywords
Forensic sciences